ArrowArtboardCreated with Sketch.Title ChevronTitle ChevronEye IconIcon FacebookIcon LinkedinIcon Mail ContactPath LayerIcon MailPositive ArrowIcon PrintTitle ChevronIcon Twitter
CEO in the news

Abe's golfing friend wins American icon Xerox for Fujifilm

CEO Komori reveals confidence and concerns over transformational deal

MITSURU OBE, Nikkei staff writer | Japan

TOKYO -- Fujifilm Holdings of Japan reached a deal on Jan. 31 to take majority control of U.S. copier maker and decades-long partner Xerox, achieving its long-held goal of making and selling office equipment throughout the world under one roof.

For Shigetaka Komori, the company's 78-year-old Chairman and CEO, this was a dream come true. It was something he thought he would never be able to accomplish during his life time. A Nikkei reporter heard him lamenting about 10 years go, "If I were 10 years younger, I would have considered buying Xerox." 

On Feb. 1, the Nikkei Asian Review caught up with Komori, who is also a close friend of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. His remarks in the interview show his confidence as well as his concern about taking over the storied American company:

"The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal do mention that an American corporate icon is being acquired by a Japanese company. But neither of them described it in any negative way. The tone of their articles is one of inevitability or of looking to Fujifilm for innovation."

Japanese corporate managers remain sensitive to American public opinion about acquiring well-known U.S. companies, especially one that so penetrated the lives of Americans that its name became a verb. Japan Inc.'s headline-making acquisitions of Columbia Pictures and Rockefeller Center in the 1980s fueled a trade war between the two countries.

Komori has reason to worry about a backlash. The takeover deal was announced the day after President Donald Trump's first State of the Union address, in which he called for putting America first, fixing "bad trade deals," protecting American jobs and rebuilding U.S. industry. Being a personal friend of Abe might also add to Komori's sense of alarm.

Fujifilm Holdings Chairman and CEO Shigetaka Komori speaks to the NIkkei Asian Review in Tokyo on Feb. 1. (Photo by Kosaku Mimura)

"We have about 300 subsidiaries, with 177 located overseas. We have been managing all of them. But this is the first time we have acquired a large corporate icon. Managing people who are very proud could be a challenge. ... Japanese often hesitate [to say what needs to be said]. You have to have strength."

Japan's corporate history is littered with stories about foreign takeovers going awry. The most recent example may be Toshiba's disastrous acquisition of U.S. nuclear-plant maker Westinghouse Electric, whose collapse last March brought the venerable Japanese industrial group to the brink of its own bankruptcy.

Komori, who has led Fujifilm for the past 18 years, is confident of commanding the respect of Xerox employees. 

"In the capitalist economy, you make money by spending it. Paper profits are unusable, no matter how big they are ... The latest scheme will allow us to take control of Xerox without spending a penny. In exchange, we give up a 75% stake in Fuji Xerox."

Fujifilm will "spend" the unrealized profit on its 75% stake in their 56-year-old joint venture, Fuji Xerox -- estimated to be worth 671 billion yen ($6.1 billion) -- to acquire 50.1% of Xerox, accomplishing the acquisition without a cash outlay.

But the deal can be looked at as Fujifilm ceding its control over the rapidly growing Asia-Pacific region to Xerox for a 50.1% stake of the U.S. company. "About 50% of [new Fuji Xerox's] profit will belong to outsiders," one analyst said. "It is also unclear if Fujifilm can integrate a giant like Xerox smoothly," the analyst added.

For now, the move was received positively in the market. After falling 8.3% on the news, Fujifilm shares rallied 10.8% in the next couple of days and ended up 0.5% over the previous week at 4,641 yen on Friday in Tokyo. Xerox shares closed the week off 3.7% at $31.63 in New York.

Ryosuke Katsura, senior analyst at SMBC Nikko Securities, said in a research note: "We think the absence of a cash outflow will be viewed positively," adding that "the stock market had harbored concerns on a cash outflow of 1.2 trillion yen to 1.3 trillion yen if Xerox had embarked on a tender offer."

"The worst-case scenario of a merger between Xerox Corp. and HP has been avoided," Katsura added in the note.

Komori had explored various possibilities of unlocking those gains, including taking Fuji Xerox public.

"I'm not worried about Carl Icahn. Xerox will be paying a special cash dividend. With his 10% stake, he will be receiving close to 30 billion yen. That will probably satisfy him. ... I am happy to meet with Icahn."

The deal calls for the U.S. company to pay $2.5 billion in cash dividends to current shareholders. Komori thinks this will go a long way toward winning over activist investor Carl Icahn, the largest Xerox shareholder, who holds a 9.7% stake.

He and fellow activist Darwin Deason have been campaigning for the ouster of Xerox CEO Jeff Jacobson. Some speculate that the duo might conclude that Fujifilm's offer is too low and decide to launch a campaign to block the combination.

Komori was confident about obtaining support of the existing shareholders, including Icahn.

"This deal is a game changer. ... The combination will create synergies and produce cost savings worth $1.7 billion a year. ... It will become much easier to increase market share ... No company is perfect. Its payroll becomes bloated over time. All organizations need a clean-up from time to time."

As the business led by Komori expands, the need to improve oversight has become a priority. The issue crystallized last year when accounting irregularities came to the surface at Fuji Xerox's Australia and New Zealand subsidiaries, an incident that forced Fujifilm to replace most executives with those of its own.    

The latest deal is aimed at further simplifying the complex partnership involving Fujifilm, Xerox and their Fuji Xerox joint venture, allowing them to develop products much faster at lower costs and distribute them to markets around the world.

Under the current arrangement, Fuji Xerox's operations are restricted to the Asia-Pacific region, and those of Xerox to Europe and North America. The combination will allow them to operate as one company and unify product development and marketing.

Cost-cutting is another important task for Komori. Joint venture Fuji Xerox, for instance, had an operating profit margin of 7.7% in the year through March 2017, compared with 9.7% for rival Canon's office equipment business in the year to December 2017. In the eyes of Komori, Fuji Xerox has been too reliant on the 'Xerox' brand and "lacks sufficient cost consciousness." He has already taken measures to rectify Fuji Xerox's proneness to high costs, and is poised to step up reform efforts after the merger with Xerox.

"Demand for copiers won't disappear soon. There will be demand from emerging economies, such as China and India as well. But this is not a market that will grow 5% a year. Only the strongest company will be able to survive."

The combination, if approved by U.S. regulators and Xerox shareholders, will create a copier maker on the same scale as industry leader HP, while eclipsing Fujifilm's domestic rivals Canon and Ricoh.

Not everyone is convinced about the merits of the deal, however. Moody's Investors Service, for one, placed Fujifilm's A1 debt rating on review for possible downgrade.

"The review for downgrade reflects the potential that Fujifilm Holdings' business profile will weaken, due to its larger exposure to the declining document business," Moody's said.

While the combination is expected to create synergies, "it is uncertain if these synergies will be enough to overcome the decline in the office printing industry and to achieve long-term revenue growth," Moody's added.

Fujifilm plans to cut 10,000 jobs at the Asia-Pacific joint venture. Komori took pains to stress that layoffs do not involve the U.S. company.

"I'd like to see a stronger product lineup in the life-science segment. We are looking to take market leadership in the field of regenerative medicine."

Fujifilm at one time had been a simple photographic film maker trying to challenge the dominance of Eastman Kodak, another American corporate titan. As demand shifted away from film, however, Fujifilm plowed heavily into research and development and branched out into new fields. Meanwhile, Kodak filed for bankruptcy in 2012.   

The acquisition of Xerox is a step back from recent efforts by the company to diversify into areas of growth, such as pharmaceuticals and cosmetics, as offices in developed markets are cutting down on paper documents. Taking control of Xerox will elevate the Japanese company's exposure to office equipment, which accounted for two-thirds of Fujifilm's and Xerox's combined sales in fiscal 2016.

Komori stressed that his company is not focusing on one or the other, but that it is pursuing growth in all areas. Still, he acknowledged that work remains to be done. 

"Of the two things I wanted to do, one was taking control of Xerox. I cannot tell you what the other is. ... [The agreement with Xerox] is like hitting a 250-yard drive shot. You still have to put the ball on the green and then into the hole, hopefully with one putt."

Komori is an athlete. He played American football in college and now plays golf with other business executives, and sometimes with Prime Minister Abe, a fellow conservative. 

Komori had his worldview shaped in Manchuria, where he was born in 1939. When he was five, Japan was defeated in World War II. His family fled Manchuria amid great confusion. "It's very miserable to get defeated. ... Life is a battle, between countries and between companies. ... It is a fight against hardship and a fight against your own weakness," he said in a previous magazine interview.

He graduated the University of Tokyo in 1963, having played on the school's American football team, the Warriors. In a message he later contributed to the team's website, Komori said, "Like in football, strategy, teamwork, speed, power and guts are important in business." Those who are afraid to fight, he said, perish.

His aggressiveness and conservative worldview brought him closer to Abe. 

After Abe resigned from his previous term as prime minister in 2007 -- only one year after taking office -- Komori organized a group of business leaders to support Abe, who had found himself in the political wilderness.

That year, Komori was appointed by Abe to the board of public broadcaster NHK and served as chairman of its management committee, channeling his conservative views into the organization that was viewed by some as leaning too liberal. 

He is already thinking about postponing his retirement, citing the need to see through the integration between Fujifilm and Xerox.

"Will the integration be complete in two to three years? It's more likely three to four years. I thought I could retire by 80, but I'll have to be around a little longer." 

Sponsored Content

About Sponsored Content This content was commissioned by Nikkei's Global Business Bureau.

You have {{numberArticlesLeft}} free article{{numberArticlesLeft-plural}} left this monthThis is your last free article this month

Stay ahead with our exclusives on Asia;
the most dynamic market in the world.

Stay ahead with our exclusives on Asia

Get trusted insights from experts within Asia itself.

Get trusted insights from experts
within Asia itself.

Try 1 month for $0.99

You have {{numberArticlesLeft}} free article{{numberArticlesLeft-plural}} left this month

This is your last free article this month

Stay ahead with our exclusives on Asia; the most
dynamic market in the world

Get trusted insights from experts
within Asia itself.

Try 3 months for $9

Offer ends October 31st

Your trial period has expired

You need a subscription to...

  • Read all stories with unlimited access
  • Use our mobile and tablet apps
See all offers and subscribe

Your full access to Nikkei Asia has expired

You need a subscription to:

  • Read all stories with unlimited access
  • Use our mobile and tablet apps
See all offers
NAR on print phone, device, and tablet media

Nikkei Asian Review, now known as Nikkei Asia, will be the voice of the Asian Century.

Celebrate our next chapter
Free access for everyone - Sep. 30

Find out more