From Endo to Dylan: how TV ads bridge the cultural divide
Japan's 'intellectual' pitchmen are happy to sell household necessities
I never had much interest in Japanese TV commercials until a friend asked me to appear in one, for an eyewear retailer. "What kind of people do this?" I wondered, before discovering I was following a long and noble tradition.
Shusaku Endo, for example, is the author of "Silence," now a powerful film directed by Martin Scorsese. A Roman Catholic of an idiosyncratic bent, he delved into the deepest and darkest areas of human experience, from World War II atrocities to the torture of 17th-century Christians.
Less well known is that Endo appeared in a Japanese TV commercial for Nescafe Gold Blend. He does some calisthenics in his garden, then sits down to a refreshing cup of coffee. "For men who understand the difference," proclaims the slogan. So well received was the ad that it was rebroadcast in updated form in 2008, 12 years after his death.
It's hard to imagine a contemporary Western literary novelist doing something similar. Indeed, American author Jonathan Franzen snubbed TV host Oprah Winfrey when she chose his novel "The Corrections" for her viewers' book club, so averse was he to having his work sullied by lowbrow commercialism.
Endo is by no means the only significant Japanese cultural figure to have fronted TV commercials. Ground-breaking film director Nagisa Oshima flogged cockroach repellent and air freshener. Ryu Murakami, author of "Almost Transparent Blue," "Audition" and many other disturbing works, has peddled Suntory whisky and Toyota cars and is currently engaged in a campaign for Epson printers. Younger pitchmen include novelists Keisuke Hada (Google Android) and Naoki Matayoshi (soft drinks and rail travel), both winners of the prestigious Akutagawa Prize for literature in 2015.
These creative people evidently felt that their status as artists would not suffer from involvement in corporate marketing campaigns. Presumably, their audiences felt the same way. It's also notable that Japanese advertisers considered serious novelists and controversial film directors to be suitable endorsers of everyday items. Franzen or British author Ian McEwan would never "lower themselves" by appearing in a TV commercial for insecticide, but neither would they be asked. As product pushers, they would be hopelessly ineffective.
The absence of taint appeals to the overseas celebrities who star in Japanese commercials but would never dream of doing the same at home. There is even a website, Japander, dedicated to their efforts. Amongst the unlikely marketers are Dennis Hopper (bath salts) and Yoko Ono and the long-dead John Lennon, who jointly hawked instant noodles in 2000.
Snobbery and populism
TV commercials are different from other advertisements in that they bring the message and the messenger right into your living room. A bond of intimacy is created. Celebrities lose their "otherness" and become ordinary people selling ordinary products -- working for money, just like the rest of us. Japanese TV ads go out of their way to demystify their spokesmen. Oshima, director of the taboo-busting "In the Realm of the Senses," prances around with a sappy grin on his face. A classical composer, a heavyweight economist and a Noh performer sip Nescafe like affable uncles.
Japan is among the few rich countries that remain relatively unshaken by populist political movements, despite two lost decades of disappointing economic growth. There are many reasons for Japan's social and political stability, but one may be the absence of a widening divide between the rulers and the ruled. In the U.S. and elsewhere, the "cognitive elites" -- the political class, technocrats and intellectuals -- no longer seem to understand or respect their fellow countrymen. Economically and culturally, they inhabit separate worlds. Franzen's snobbery toward potential readers foreshadowed Hillary Clinton's dismissal during the U.S. presidential campaign of many Donald Trump supporters as "deplorables."
A healthier society may be one in which the cultural divide is much narrower and serious artists are happy to be beamed into people's homes to sell mass market items. After all, some of the greatest American writers were comfortable with making product endorsements. Mark Twain pitched Conklin fountain pens, and Ernest Hemingway and John Steinbeck lent their charisma to beer ads. More recently, Bob Dylan, winner of the 2016 Nobel Prize in Literature, has appeared in commercials for Chrysler cars and Victoria's Secret lingerie -- thereby showing that high artistic achievement can coexist with commerce and fun.
Endo, who did TV ads for Canon and NEC as well as Nescafe, would probably approve heartily. I know I do.
Peter Tasker is an analyst for Tokyo-based Arcus Research and once appeared in a Japanese TV commercial.