ISLAMABAD Two international lending institutions and Pakistan's central bank have raised concerns about the debt burden of a huge China-led infrastructure program on the country's improving but still-fragile finances.
Surging Chinese imports for the initiative, known as the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor program, have complicated Pakistan's balance of payments problems during its second year of economic recovery following a decade of conflict with Taliban insurgents and their al-Qaida allies.
Chinese machinery imports for power generation and transport infrastructure are forecast to reach $27.8 billion in the fiscal year ending in June 2021. The CPEC aims to build roads, railways and energy infrastructure across Pakistan.
The Pakistani government has said that further projects costing $16 billion are expected to be implemented by 2030, while preparations are continuing for additional elements following negotiations in December that expanded the program's overall cost to $55 billion from $46 billion.
Pakistan and China have been close diplomatic and military allies since the 1960s. Underlining the broadening of the relationship through CPEC, a 90-member honor guard from the People's Liberation Army participated in Pakistan's national day military parade in Islamabad on March 23 -- the first appearance by Chinese troops.
However, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have both expressed concerns about the financial strains caused by the CPEC program. "Sovereign guarantees associated with the CPEC project [will] elevate fiscal risks over the medium term," the World Bank said in its Global Economic Prospects Report for 2017, published in January.
In October last year, the IMF said the execution of CPEC projects would create a surge in foreign direct investment and other external funding inflows, but the import requirements of these projects "will likely offset a significant share of these inflows, such that the current-account deficit would widen."
In a further illustration of international concern, credit ratings agency Fitch said on Feb. 6 that Pakistan's "increasing gross external financing needs could increase the country's vulnerability to shifts in investor sentiment." Fitch affirmed its noninvestment grade "B" rating for Pakistan's sovereign debt, with a stable outlook.
The State Bank of Pakistan, the central bank, has been more cautious on the impact of CPEC, but warned in a monetary policy statement in January that "going forward, with the risks to the external sector, the need of financial inflows would grow further."
Prominent local economists have also expressed serious concerns. Hafiz Pasha, a former finance minister, and Ashfaq Hassan Khan, a former adviser to the Finance Ministry, have estimated that CPEC loans will add $14 billion to Pakistan's total public debt, raising it to $90 billion by the fiscal year ending June 2019.
"The government policy of short-term borrowing is risky and at a high cost," Pasha said, speaking on local TV in January.
Noting that Pakistan has extended sovereign guarantees to CPEC project loans and subsequent profit repatriations, Pasha and Hassan projected that debt servicing payments will rise to $8.3 billion in the fiscal year ending in 2019, widening the current-account deficit to 4% of gross domestic product from less than 1% in the fiscal year ending June 2015, the year before CPEC was agreed.
Without an improbable increase in exports to at least $36 billion by the fiscal year ending June 2019, from the currently stagnant level of $24 billion, Pakistan will have to request renewed balance of payments support from the IMF by the year ending June 2019, they said.
ALARMIST OR ALARMING Mohiuddin Aazim, an independent economic analyst based in Karachi, said the projections by Pasha and Hassan are alarmist because they classify borrowing for CPEC power projects as public debt, while the government and multilateral lenders consider it private debt held by independent power producers.
"Foreign debt servicing in [the] case of energy projects will be the responsibility of Chinese companies that will come and set up energy production units, so this should not create an additional debt servicing burden on the part of Pakistan," Aazim said in an interview. "The much-feared increase in our import bills would be compensated [for] by a simultaneous increase in foreign direct investment that these Chinese and other foreign companies will bring in."
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar has also played down concerns about Pakistan's indebtedness. In an article published by local English-language newspapers on Jan. 31, he said external debt servicing obligations would not average more than $5 billion a year up to the fiscal year ending in June 2021.
However, economists using Ministry of Finance data have predicted that the external account deficit will soon widen to unsustainable levels, requiring renewed balance of payments support from the IMF.
"Debt servicing and fuel imports for the new power plants will increase external payment obligations quite substantially in the next three years," said Sakib Sherani, CEO of Macro Economic Insights, an Islamabad-based consultancy. "While Pakistan's current [foreign exchange] reserves position is adequate, it is likely to need to head to the IMF by 2019 at the latest," Sherani said.
To strengthen its foreign exchange buffer, Pakistan negotiated fresh foreign loans totaling $25 billion in the three fiscal years ending in June 2016, while spending $11.95 billion on external debt servicing, the Finance Ministry reported in October. Total foreign public debt increased to $57.7 billion from $48.1 billion, at a cumulative growth rate of 6.3% a year. In the three-year period ending June 2016, the ratio of net debt to GDP remained unchanged at 60.2%, while the fiscal deficit was reduced to 4.6% of GDP from 8.2%.
Since returning to the international capital markets in 2014, after a seven-year absence, Pakistan has issued eurobonds and sukuk (Islamic bonds) worth $4.5 billion to build up its foreign currency reserves. A $1 billion five-year sukuk issued in October was priced at a historically low yield of 5.5%, compared with 6.75% for an identical issue in November 2014. Foreign-exchange reserves peaked at $24.1 billion in November, but fell to $21.7 billion in the week ending March 24.
The concerns about CPEC come as optimism about Pakistan's economic future rises, thanks to cooling domestic conflict and growing consumer demand. Pakistan offers investors a market of about 200 million consumers, about 70% of whom are 30 or younger.
Coupled with the surge in domestic consumption that followed the decisive phase of the conflict in 2014 and 2015, CPEC will push Pakistan's GDP growth to between 4.9% and 5.3% in the fiscal year ending June 2017, according to recently upgraded forecasts by multilateral lenders and ratings agencies.
In its Global Economic Prospects Report, the World Bank revised its forecast for Pakistan's GDP growth in 2016-2017 to 5.2% from 5%. It said CPEC-associated improvements in energy and infrastructure, as well as recovering agricultural output and external demand for exports, would push growth to 5.5% in the fiscal year ending in June 2018 and 5.8% in the fiscal year to June 2019.
However, in a separate outlook report published in November, the World Bank warned: "Pakistan's continued growth is not guaranteed."
The bank added: "In the short to medium term, sustained progress on energy reforms, CPEC implementation and widening the tax net will be important. Without these structural reforms and other efforts to improve the investment climate, Pakistan's rate of investment will remain weak and its consumption-driven growth will eventually slow down."